Ricotta cheesecake, or simply “ricotta cake” as it’s known around these parts, is a tricky dish to get right. I couldn’t find any recipes for this fluffy textured Italian-style cheesecake that’s so popular in Sydney Inner West, so I had to concoct my own. It’s taken eight attempts to finally come up with one that I’m completely happy with. The neighbours are sick to death of eating my rejects!
Fig Jam and Lime Cordial Ricotta Cake
Filling:
- 750g dry ricotta (edit: you can use well drained normal ricotta if you can’t buy the drier style – which is what I’ve done here)
- 375g thick sour cream
- 45g cornflour (cornstarch)
- 3 eggs, separated
- 1½ tsp vanilla
- 225g icing sugar mixture (not pure icing sugar)
June’s Pastry
- 250g unsalted butter
- 300g plain flour
- 100g bread/bakers/continental flour
- 150g icing sugar mixture (not pure icing sugar)
- 2 eggs
Note: June’s pastry makes this recipe extra special, but if you were in a hurry, you could probably get away with substituting any sweet shortcrust pastry recipe, or even frozen sheets (though I haven’t tried it myself). The filling is remarkably easy, so if you cheat on the pastry, this would be quite a simple dish to put together.
1. Make a batch of pastry, following the instructions here. Chill until required. Spray oil over the base and sides of a large, deep 10”/25cm flan tin with a removable base.
2. Remove the pastry from the fridge, and roll out on a flour dusted surface or sheet of Bake until the pastry is wide enough to fully line the bottom and sides of the flan tin (you won’t need all the dough). Gently fit the pastry into the flan tin and smooth out carefully. Allow the dough to come up above the sides slightly (to allow for shrinkage). This is a fiddly process as the pastry is quite soft. Use a little flour for dusting, and feel free to patch the pastry if it tears. Preheat oven to 150C with fan.
3. Make the filling: put the ricotta and sour cream in a large mixing bowl, and mix together with a large fork, breaking up the lumps as much as possible. Here’s a photo of the dry ricotta, so you know what to buy. Don’t make the mistake of getting baked ricotta – you want dry fresh ricotta.
4. Add the cornflour, icing sugar mixture, vanilla and egg yolks, and continue to stir until well combined. Note: only two egg yolks shown in this photo, but you need to add three. These photos were taken when I was making the smaller cake below.
5. Beat the egg whites in a separate bowl until stiff. Still using the fork, stir a large spoonful of egg white into the ricotta mixture until the mix lightens, then gently fold the remaining egg whites into the mix. Pour into the pastry lined tin.
5. Carefully place the cake into the oven and bake for 45 – 55 minutes at 150C with fan. The cake will be ready when the crust is brown and the filling is set. Do not overbake. Cracks may appear on the surface, but don’t panic, as the cake will still taste wonderful. Once cooked, allow the cake to cool completely in the oven with the door ajar, then refrigerate for several hours or overnight to allow the cake to fully set. It really is best if you can make it the day before you need it, as it tastes much better on the second day.
6. Dust the cake with a generous amount of icing sugar before serving!
. . . . .
This cake can also be made in an 8″/20cm springform round tin. To make the filling for the smaller sized cake, use the following ingredients:
- 500g dry ricotta (edit: you can use well drained normal ricotta if you can’t buy the drier style – which is what I’ve done here)
- 250g thick sour cream
- 30g cornflour (cornstarch)
- 2 eggs, separated
- 1 tsp vanilla
- 150g icing sugar mixture (not pure icing sugar)
The one I made cracked, but it still tasted fantastic! Bake the smaller cake for 40 – 45 minutes, or until the pastry is browned and the top is set. Because the cake is baked at a relatively slow temperature, I’ve found it best to use metal tins to ensure the pastry cooks and browns properly.
© copyright 2009 by Fig Jam and Lime Cordial. All rights reserved.
Hello aunty Celia,
Thank you for the ricotta cake.
We shared it for afternoon tea while danger mouse was sleeping.
It tasted like the inside of a panzarotti from Papa’s pasticceria.
Bye, brave tiger+scary dragon
Glad you like it! Maybe we can try to figure out panzarotti as well…
Thanks Celia, you’re a star. I’ll try this ASAP and also pass it on to other ricotta cake devotees who have tried in vain to replicate Papa’s/Sulfaro’s versions. Can’t wait!!
Thanks Rob! :)
Oh wow…it was worth the 8 attempts to perfect this recipe Celia – well done! It looks perfect – kind of a cross between the Sulfaros and Papas version, with the best of both…I always thought that something in between their two offerings would be perfect and I think you might just have created it. Even your pastry looks better than theirs. All this from looking at the picture alone. Ofcourse if you actually sent one of those slices my way right now I might be able to give a more informed opinion…. :)
I am definately going to give this a try on the weekend. A question: by dry ricotta do you mean the standard ricotta that has been drained well or do you mean the dry ricotta sold in blocks like cheese?
Spice Girl, two words. Lactose Intolerant. :)
But if you do give it a whirl, I used dry ricotta from Paesanella, which is basically a dry form of the fresh ricotta, sold in blocks. But not the baked ricotta, that’s quite different. I’ll upload a photo. I’m going to experiment to see if it works as well with fresh ricotta that’s been really well drained in a sieve – it should.
Celia
MMMMMMMMMMMMMMM! Makes me wonder what other cheeses you can use for cake.
Beautiful cake – we sampled it last night and my two year old stole half of mine. Can’t wait to try making it, though at the moment am too in love with the yoghurt cake recipe to consider anything else.
hi aunty celia!
just wanted to say how much i absolutely LOVE your website & all the yummy food pictures you put up each day…!! haha checking FJALC has been worked into my daily internet schedule now! =)
on another note, how are you? hope all is well in sydney-town =) love to uncle peter, the boys & grand uncle/aunty!
Hey gorgeous, nice to hear from you! I’ve sent you an email…
Thanks for sharing your fantastic ricotta cake with us – it was great the first day, but as you suggested it was even better the next day and best the day after. It seems to need a couple of days to be a bit firmer. Thanks again (I even might have to attempt to make it.)
Cheers, Caz, I’m glad you liked it!
Hi,
I made this recipe last night.
The bottom crust didnt turn out that good, next time I will tri to bake the crust for 10 min and pour the filling and bake it again.
I like the filling , very light. Thanks for sharing the recipe.
Thanks for the feedback, Hen!