
Our apple butter is a byproduct of pectin production – it’s never a preserve that we deliberately set out to make. For that reason, I’ve been reluctant to post our recipe in the past, because it’s such a loose construction – the few ingredients will vary depending on the type of apples we’re using and our mood on the day.
But…given the numerous kind requests I’ve had since posting our muesli cookie recipe, here is a rough guide on how we make it. Please understand that it’s not a fixed formula – if you use sweet apples, you might need less sugar, and the spice mix can be adjusted to suit your personal preferences.
We start with the pulp leftover from boiling apples to make pectin. If you’re not making pectin, you could peel, core and chop up the apples, then cook them in a little water until they go soft and mushy. We try to use either green or Pink Lady apples – as I said, you might want to reduce the sugar if you’re using sweeter fruit.
In a large mixing bowl, combine together:
- 4 cups of apple pulp
- 1 cup white sugar
- 1½ cups brown sugar
- juice of 2 large lemons (about 150ml)
- ½ teaspoon ground cinnamon
- ¼ teaspoon allspice
Stir well, then pour the flavoured pulp into a large roasting pan – I use an Emile Henry clay one. Spread the mixture out evenly with a spatula, then bake in a preheated 150C with fan oven for 2 – 3 hours.
Make sure you stir the mixture frequently (every 15 minutes or so), scraping into the corners of the pan to ensure it doesn’t catch. Over the cooking time, the apple butter will darken and thicken – pull it out of the oven when it’s a little bit looser than you’d like, as it will thicken up in the jar.
Spoon the hot apple butter into clean jars, seal them tightly, and then process them in a hot water bath. From our experience, jars of apple butter processed in this way keep well for at least a year.



















