
Part 2 of my geeky bread adventures!
. . . . .
After the success of our earlier pot baking experiments, I thought it was worth trying out some of the suggestions offered in the comments to my last post. The results were very interesting!
Using my 90% hydration dough (made with a 50/50 blend of bakers flour and remilled semolina flour), I tried baking the dough in three different ways:
- in a cold enamel roaster, starting off in a cold oven
- in a cold enamel roaster, going into a preheated hot oven
- in a presoaked Römertopf clay pot – the risen dough went into the soaked pot and then into a cold oven
. . . . .
Cold enamel roaster, cold oven
After the dough was risen and shaped, I slashed it and turned it into the small Falcon roaster, then placed the covered pot into a cold oven, and turned the heat up to 220C with fan. As the oven was cold, I baked it for 25 minutes covered, 20 minutes uncovered, then 10 minutes at 175C with fan.
This combination produced a magnificent looking loaf (top photo) with an elastic, holey crumb. Whereas our preheated pot/hot oven bake had produced a crispy, thin crust, this method produced a chewier, toothsome crust. It’s good to know this works – it’s the ideal way to bake a loaf without the expense of preheating the oven, or the angst of manhandling a blazing hot empty pot.
The huge holes are unusual, and I suspect that they’re a result of how my starter Priscilla was behaving on the day (and my dodgy shaping), rather than the baking method.

. . . . .
Cold enamel roaster, hot oven
For the second attempt, I shaped the dough into two small round loaves and, once they had risen, I slashed them and placed them into the cold large roaster. The covered pot then went into a preheated hot oven, and was given 20 minutes covered, 20 minutes uncovered, followed by 10 minutes at 175C with fan.
The advantage of this method is that it avoids the need to maneouvre a hot pot in and out of the oven. Pete was of the opinion that this would work with the enamel cookware, as it was thin enough to heat up very quickly, but possibly less well with heavier pots. Having said that, my friend Emilie bakes the most magnificent loaves in a non-preheated cast iron dutch oven!

These loaves were delicious, but again with a heavier crust than the hot pot/hot oven combination produced. The crumb was holey and elastic…

. . . . .
Presoaked Römertopf baker, cold oven
As you all know, I adore my Römertopf bakers, but I don’t have a good track record of baking bread in them (the loaf pans work well though).
For my first attempt a few years ago, I preheated the soaked baker in the oven, then took out the hot pot and plonked my dough into it. The minute I did, I heard the glaze on the clay baker crack – the thermal shock of the cold dough on the hot base was too great. Sadly, that Römertopf ended up as a garden pot.
Recently I tried again – I soaked the pot and put it into a cold oven, but I forgot to grease or line the base, and this is what I ended up with…


I finally figured it out on my third attempt. I soaked the base and lid of the baker in a sink of warm water, then turned the shaped and risen sourdough onto a large sheet of parchment. After slashing, it was lowered into the clay baker, covered, and placed into a cold oven, which was turned up to 220C with fan. The dough was given 25 minutes at 220C with fan, followed by 20 minutes with the lid off, and a further 10 minutes at 175C with fan.
The end result was this magnificent, well risen loaf…

This is the perfect way to bake a high hydration loaf if you’re seeking to make a soft crusted bread – the water from both the dough and the soaked pot ensure that the crust stays flexible and moist, and the crumb is reasonably close and even. It would make a great sandwich bread…

. . . . .
So there you have it – the culmination of our week of bread experiments.
I think our preferred loaves (using our bakers flour/remilled semolina formula) are the ones we get when we preheat the roaster. That seems to produce the thin, crisp crust that everyone enjoys the most, but I’m sure I’ll be using all three of the different methods above in the future. As Em pointed out, sometimes it’s just too hot in the middle of summer to have the oven running any longer than absolutely necessary.
Oh, and remember our failed Romy loaf? It was torn apart and baked in a very low oven (100C) for a few hours – it made the best croutons we’ve ever eaten!

Read Full Post »